When he is placed on oxygen, the oxygen-induced respiratory drive decreases and the pCO2 rises some. However, the declining pH actually passes 7.4 before the pCO2 reaches the normal level of 40 mm Hg. This is because the renal compensation is "uncovered" when the pCO2 rises and it can't respond fast enough to avoid an overshoot in pH. Now the tables are turned and the kidney is causing a mild metabolic acidosis (decreased pH because the bicarbonate level is too low). This will resolve over a few hours as the kidneys respond.
In patients with severe COPD and severe respiratory alkalosis, a sudden treatment with pure oxygen resulting in a sudden drop in breathing rate has been known to produce dangerous levels of acidosis by this mechanism.
Blood gases:
Room Air 100% oxygen pO2 43 mm Hg 452 mm Hg pCO2 22 34 pH 7.51 7.38